Showing posts with label Privacy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Privacy. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 28, 2017

Discussion: SCOTUS, Carpenter & Call Detail Records

November 28, 2017

Discussion: SCOTUS, Carpenter & Call Detail Records

On November 29, 2017, the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) will hear arguments in the case of Carpenter v. US.  At the heart of the arguments is whether or not the government (i.e., law enforcement) need a search warrant to obtain records from cellular providers for suspects in criminal incidents to help determine the location of those criminal suspects at or around the time of an incident.  Previously, as detailed in the USA Today article here, SCOTUS and lower courts have upheld that a search warrant is not required because the records are not subject to Fourth Amendment privacy restrictions due to the fact that the data (i.e., the records) are transmitted to a third party, being the cellular provider.  This is what is known as the “Third Party Doctrine”.  It has been cited in previous cases where a third party, such as a utility company, holds records that may be relevant in a criminal investigation and the burden of documentation on the government has heretofore been a subpoena for records, not a search warrant.  Because a search warrant requires probable cause to be stated, the standard would be higher to obtain the records.

Think of it this way:  Subpoena = “I want this”
                                     Search Warrant = “I want this, and here is why”


Call Detail Records… Sort of

Setting the Records Straight

I’ve read a lot online about this case.  A recent posting on PoliceOne.com erroneously leads the reader to believe that this case is about data contained on the cell phone, much like the often-argued Apple vs. FBI cases that keep popping up in the wake of active shooter/terrorist incidents (Read this blog’s take on that here:  https://prodigital4n6.com/clash-of-the-titans-apple-vs-the-u-s-government/ ).  Let me be clear: This case is not about cell phone data, forcing people to hand over their passcodes or allowing the government to pry into your device!  This case is about cellular location data subscribers virtually never see.  It is about records of cell site location data stored with your cellular provider, along with sending and receiving phone numbers for calls and texts, duration of calls and potentially locations of cell sites used for data transmissions when you check Facebook or your email.  You never see most of this data and if you call your cellular provider, they won’t give it to you without a subpoena. 

To Get A Warrant Or Not?  That is the Question!

Some brief background is in order before opining on this subject…
I’m a former law enforcement investigator with 15 years total experience.  I worked as the sole investigative member for my agency on the Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force for several years and have investigated hundreds of electronically-facilitated crimes, which meant that I had to author dozens of search warrants and subpoenas.  In Virginia, there is a law that allows police to obtain subscriber information only for users of internet service providers in child exploitation cases.  These “administrative subpoenas” need to be signed by a prosecutor and can simply be faxed to the provider to obtain name, address, phone number, email address and any other registrant information for the user of a screen name, email address, IP address, etc.  It is to be used in child exploitation cases only and no additional records are available through this process.

Each and every prosecuting attorney I’ve ever been trained by or worked with (and I’ve worked with some of the best at electronic crime prosecution) has a rule:  When in doubt, get a search warrant.  In fact, for cellular call detail records (CDRs), there is often a need to bypass a subpoena and get a search warrant, especially when requesting more than simple records – things like text message content.  You see, the law distinguishes between things like simple records and unique content of text messages, so the burden of the request is naturally higher when the police ask for content of email, text messages, etc. vs. simple records of who logged onto the service, when and from where.  It’s an important distinction and one that SCOTUS will no doubt delve into in great detail during arguments in this case.


 These things are everywhere!

Since leaving law enforcement and for nearly the past 4 years, I’ve been working mainly civil cases in the digital forensic field in a litigation support arena.  I’ve also been working cases involving analysis and mapping of cellular call detail records, so I’ve been involved in assisting attorneys on verbiage for the requests of these records, obtaining the records, analyzing the records and using them to prove or disprove location, link analysis and other items of interest in litigation.  A few of these cases have been retained by criminal defendants, so I have the benefit of experience at the prosecution end and the defense end to add credence to the next bit of information…

It’s very simple:  In most cases, getting a search warrant helps the prosecution and helps bolster the credibility of the evidence.  In most cases where a search warrant isn’t obtained and that fact is argued by the defense, the arguments help to bolster the defense and sometimes leads the evidence, such as cellular call detail records, to be thrown out. 

That being the case, my question to government investigators everywhere is, why not just get a search warrant anyway?

Yes, there are exceptions to every “search warrant rule”, exigency being the most obvious.  But absent exigency, a search warrant should probably be sought. 

Investigative Lead vs. Evidence

Part of what’s the heart of this argument is whether or not CDRs constitute an investigative lead or evidence.  When police request a “tower dump” of all devices connected to a particular cell site in a given time frame around a crime to help generate a potential suspect list or prove/disprove a suspect was in the area at the time of the crime, that serves as an investigative lead, but it can also quickly turn into evidence.  I would submit that investigative leads alone do not require a search warrant.  By their very nature, they are lacking in specific evidence in support of them, so a search warrant likely isn’t feasible.  However, I would further submit that a “tower dump” and the data derived therefrom also doesn’t fall under the category of a specific subscriber’s (i.e., target’s) call detail records.  They are records maintained by the cellular provider, but not specific to any one subscriber.

Only after a suspect list has been developed and substantial information gathered to develop actionable intelligence can we start to cross the bridge into evidence.  It also cannot be overlooked that sometimes, cellular location evidence serves to exonerate a suspect, by proving he (or his device) was not in the area at the time of the incident.  Either way, the importance of evidentiary data in, contrast to investigative leads, dictates that obtaining a search warrant is likely the prudent move.

Wrapping it Up


Back when the Third Party Doctrine was originally held, wireless cell phones were just an idea.  In 2017, we use them to stay connected in our everyday lives.  They help us keep in contact with friends and loved-ones, facilitate banking transactions, arrange transportation and much more.  The devices themselves store a very large amount of data, but they cannot do it without internet connectivity, which is what the cellular providers do for us.  The weight of cellular location evidence in both criminal and civil cases has grown exponentially in the modern era and will only keep growing as time goes on and cellular networks transition from 4G to 5G technology.

My prediction: SCOTUS will hold that the government needs a search warrant to obtain cellular records of a specific subscriber or target of an investigation.  However, they need to understand and explicitly distinguish between records for a specific subscriber needing a search warrant vs. tools police use to generate investigative leads, for which the burden of the request should be much lower.  Such is the case when requesting tower dumps.  Only by making that distinction clear will they serve to help answer additional questions in subsequent cases and put the matter entirely to rest… until next time!

Author:
Patrick J. Siewert
Principal Consultant
Professional Digital Forensic Consulting, LLC
Virginia DCJS #11-14869
Based in Richmond, Virginia
Available Wherever You Need Us!


We Find the Truth for a Living!

Computer Forensics -- Mobile Forensics -- Specialized Investigation

About the Author:

Patrick Siewert is the Principal Consultant of Pro Digital Forensic Consulting, based in Richmond, Virginia.  In 15 years of law enforcement, he investigated hundreds of high-tech crimes, incorporating digital forensics into the investigations, and was responsible for investigating some of the highest jury and plea bargain child exploitation investigations in Virginia court history.  Patrick is a graduate of SCERS, BCERT, the Reid School of Interview & Interrogation and multiple online investigation schools (among others). He continues to hone his digital forensic expertise in the private sector while growing his consulting & investigation business marketed toward litigators, professional investigators and corporations, while keeping in touch with the public safety community as a Law Enforcement Instructor.

Twitter: @ProDigital4n6

Friday, March 6, 2015

Digital Forensics for Private & Corporate Investigators



March 6, 2015

Digital Forensics for Private & Corporate Investigators

We’ve recently received a few inquiries from our partners in private investigations asking about the services we offer, our capabilities insofar as mobile forensic data extraction and other related services.  It dawned on me that the potential for private investigators to utilize a trained digital forensic examiner is huge and mostly untapped.  Further, there are areas of corporate investigations that Human Resources and IT staff can utilize digital forensics to help bolster their cases of company violations of acceptable computer/mobile device usage, intellectual property theft and internal information security breaches.  So for the benefit of colleagues working in those industries, we’ll detail some cases in which our digital forensic expertise can help you & your clients and, in many cases, close the door to potential civil liability.

Background

For legal reasons I won’t bore my readers with, when I left law enforcement, I immediately became a certified Private Investigator.  As such, I also belong to a statewide group of Private Investigators who meet every other month to exchange ideas, tactics, expertise, knowledge, etc.  And while I don’t own or operate a Private Investigations firm, the overlap of digital forensics into Private Investigations is something that I felt should be embraced and marketed toward.  However (and at the risk that some of my colleagues in the group will read this), I will note that many of my contemporaries in Private Investigations are older, retired former law enforcement.  Some of them have been retired for 20 years or more, long before the advent of main stream digital forensics, especially in the private sector.  This article is not specifically for them, but for all private investigators who feel their cases may be lacking in real, solid evidence to help their clients.

Another repeated theme in this blog is the noted differences between information technology (IT) and digital forensics.  As part of this article, my hope is also to get IT and Human Resource personnel in corporate environments thinking about how a trained, experienced digital forensic practitioner can really help them in the unfortunate event they have an employee who violates one or more of several policies.  Frankly, calling in a digital forensic examiner will likely be the best decision you make to help “cover your ass” from potential litigation following an incident.

Digital Forensics for Private Investigators

There are many different types of private investigators.  To be sure, the networking group I belong to has corporate private investigators who work for larger law firms all the way down to the ‘lone wolf’ private investigator who conducts hours of surveillance on cheating spouses, insurance fraud suspects and other miscellaneous misanthropes.  In the end, their jobs all boil down to one thing: clients and/or corporations are paying the private investigators to perform work that the police either won’t do or can’t do because of any number of limitations.  So if the police routinely use digital forensics in their investigations, why shouldn’t private investigators do the same?

Of course, I know the answer is cost.  However, there are many things that motivate clients.  Fear, money, revenge, power and plain ole ego are just a few.  The level of desperation and/or motivation in your client will dictate how much money they are willing to spend to help prove (or disprove) their case.  For example, if a wife suspects her husband of cheating and she stands to gain a large sum of money through potential divorce proceedings, there could be a ton of usable, verifiable data on her husband’s old cell phone that could help prove the case.  Text messages, pictures, email, video, web history, voicemail – all of these are potentially recoverable artifacts  If the client stands to gain thousands (or millions) of dollars in the divorce, the cost of $1000-1500 for a digital forensic exam on the old phone could be a proverbial drop in the bucket compared to the potential benefit.  What’s more, when the data is extracted properly & reported, it can’t be manipulated.  It is what it is, right there in black-and-white.  That old phone that was thrown in a desk drawer now becomes the key evidence in your divorce case.

Decidedly less “seedy” is the potential for digital forensics to help in other civil law cases like texting-while-driving and distracted driving personal injury cases.  Most smart phones contain a feature (or more than one) to catalog all of the activity on the device.  When a private investigator is hired by a law firm to investigate a personal injury case where the accusation is the responsible party was texting while driving, the proper extraction & analysis of the data on the phone will show all activity leading up to and right around the time of the accident.  In the totality of circumstances, this can add value to the attorney’s case and force a cleaner settlement faster.  Again, the cost for these services could be negligible compared to the overall scope of the law suit.
I’ve seen over time that the biggest challenge for a private digital forensic practitioners is to get potential clients, such as attorneys and private investigators, into the mindset of simply thinking about digital evidence and how it can help add value to their cases.  These examples are just a few, but they represent a huge contingent of private investigations.  

Digital Forensics in Corporate Investigations

Perhaps even more ubiquitous in the overall scope of work in America is the potential for employee violations of varying degree while at work.  It’s a tried and true concept that, as a business owner, your employees will account for the majority of your theft, data liability and loss.  This is true for the clerk at 7-11 all the way up to the Administrative Assistant to the President of Acme Company with 25 years of service.  Indeed, I’ve seen embezzlement happen within law enforcement agencies, so no industry is immune. 
But the fact remains that no company can function adequately in 2015 without technology.  Whether you’re a small one or two-man operation or a huge multinational bank, technology makes business easier and saves us time, but it also creates another potential area for loss.  It also gives employees another outlet to waste company time, which is yet another form of loss.  So how can digital forensics help?  No company wants to fire their employees.  But there will come a time when, as a business owner, corporate investigator and/or human resource practitioner, you will have to discipline and/or terminate one or more employees because of inappropriate activity or behavior.  The biggest fear when this happens is civil liability – “If I fire this person, will they sue me civilly?” 

I suggest the answer lies in your early and appropriate use of a trained digital forensic expert.  As a brief side note, you may think your IT person has these skills & abilities, but I can assure you most of them do not (see previous article on selecting a Digital Forensic Examiner here: http://prodigital4n6.blogspot.com/2015/02/selecting-competent-digital-forensic.html)

For example, if you work in human resources or corporate investigations for First National Bank and you get an internet activity report that one of your employees in the call center has bypassed the web filters and is looking at pornography while at work, that’s an obvious violation of acceptable use policy.  But how do you investigate and prove that?  If there is any potential (and there is always a potential) for civil liability, a trained digital forensic examiner can be called in to seize the evidence, examine the evidence, report the evidence and help solidify your case for suspension and/or termination.  This evidence is vital to helping to close the door on potential litigation and it bears repeating – there is ALWAYS a potential for litigation for wrongful suspension, termination, etc.  It doesn’t matter if you’re a multi-national corporation or a small LLC, you have to take the appropriate steps to make sure you are covered when and if you get served with civil suit papers.  Conversely, if your company has been served with a lawsuit which claims some sort of damage related to use of electronic devices, a digital forensic examiner can be called in to help determine if any liability exists and to what extent.

Most data security breaches also happen from the inside, not from external hackers as we often see in the media.  Whether intentional or not, the potential for an employee to plug a malware-laden USB thumb drive into your system, thus affecting the entire network, is real and happens quite often.  Once the malware, worm or other virus-like program spreads its way through your network, there’s no telling what type of data loss could occur before detection.  Once these incidents are discovered, it’s important to find out where they originated because 1) the origination date, time & location helps determine how much loss is associated with your data breach and 2) it helps prevent further breaches from the same source.  If the attack was intentional and perhaps caused by a disgruntled employee, there could be legal (criminal & civil) implications as well.  In cases like this, I can’t stress enough the importance for a digital forensic expert to be called immediately.  It’s very much like first-aid for your corporate network – the network has been “injured”, now you need to call an ambulance (i.e., a digital forensic examiner). To be frank, IT staff may find out about the breach and be able to tell you some things about how the breach affected the network, but they aren’t generally equipped to handle digital evidence, examine data and testify in official proceedings.

Wouldn’t it give you some real peace-of-mind to know the digital evidence of these types of incidents is right there in the employee file?  If litigation should take place, even years later, when your attorney shows the opposing party the signed acceptable use policy and the digital evidence, backed by an experienced, trained digital forensic examiner, your suit will virtually melt away.  Again, the data doesn’t lie.

Conclusions

The examples listed here are just a few among the dozens of areas where a digital forensic examiner can help both private investigators and corporate representatives in companies of any size.  The key is to get in the right mindset from the start.  There will almost always be a moment where you, as the investigator, jilted spouse, human resource professional, IT representative or corporate investigator are shocked at what you’ve discovered.  Once that initial shock wears off, that is the time to start thinking about what to do next.  One of your first thoughts should be to do what is necessary to secure the evidence you need to take appropriate action and call a professional to handle that evidence.  From there, it’s up to the proper selection of the people you want and need to help in your case.

I hate clichés, but sometimes clichés are cliché for a reason… And it’s very true that an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.  Contact us to find out how we can help you get closer to your pound of cure.

Author:
Patrick J. Siewert, SCERS, BCERT, LCE
Principal Consultant
Professional Digital Forensic Consulting, LLC
Based in Richmond, Virginia
Available Globally
Web: www.ProDigital4n6.com
Twitter: ProDigital4n6

Wednesday, January 14, 2015

Searching for Artifacts in Private Messaging App: Cyber Dust





January 14, 2015

Searching for Artifacts in Private Messaging App: Cyber Dust

As a burgeoning entrepreneur, I'm a big fan of the TV Show "Shark Tank".  I often tell people that when I was a young cop, I used to watch "Cops" to see what to do and, more importantly, what NOT to do.  The same is true for my affinity for "Shark Tank".  Several very successful business people from various industries get to bid or pass on business opportunities from likely entrepreneurs.  It's not only great advertising for the young business owners, but it has the potential to be very lucrative if one of the "Sharks" happens to make them an offer on their proposal.  One of the more entertaining Sharks is Mark Cuban, outspoken owner of the Dallas Mavericks NBA team and shrewd, modern business man. 
 
Recently, Cuban has been hard at work promoting a mobile app that was brought to him while on “Shark Tank” called Cyber Dust.  According to his own description from The Tonight Show, “…it’s text messaging, but within 24 seconds after it’s read, the message disappears. So that way you can talk to your agent, you can talk about your friends, you can talk about anything… I don’t want to leave a digital footprint, so we came up with Cyber Dust.Once it’s gone, it’s gone.”  In fact, when I recently posed the question about a possible forensic footprint being left behind by Cyber Dust to Cuban on Twitter, he replied promptly:


Being the consummate contrarian that I am, I decided to take Cuban up on his quasi-challenge and use a couple of different mobile forensic tools to try and recover data from a mobile device that was using Cyber Dust.  My results were admittedly mixed, but interesting nonetheless.

Background

Cyber Dust is available in both iOS and Android platforms and indeed was examined on both (detailed later).  The app is a simple messaging app where users can send messages that have a half-life and disappear 24 seconds after being opened.  Pictures can also be sent back-and-forth and, if you are “sneaky” enough to try and take a screen shot of the picture that the other party sent, it notifies them of this.  Messages you send can also be “pinned” (saved for a time) on your device, but you cannot “pin” the messages of the person with whom you are communicating.  There are other features too like “blast” messaging and searching for users by user name.  It’s a fairly simple, easy-to-use app that has it’s plusses and minuses, as with all things.

For this [admittedly] very basic experiment, I downloaded the Cyber Dust app on both my iPhone 5s running iOS 8.1.2 and my lab test phone, a pre-pay Samsung Android phone (model SPH-M830) running OS version 4.1.2 (Jelly Bean).  Full disclosure: I am NOT an Android user as my primary device. 

I used two mobile forensic tools to try and locate data on the devices – Lantern v. 4.5.4 and Cellebrite Universal Forensic Extraction Device (UFED) for PC, v. 4.1.0.178. 

Testing Parameters

I actually conducted two tests in this case.  For both, I compiled a list of key words which would be used in the message strings between me and another user (iPhone) and between me and myself on a separate account (Android).  These key words were:

  • Cyberdust (all one word)

  • Bababooey

  • Xylophone (which was also “pinned” in the message string)

  • BlogMaverick (all one word, with the B and M capitalized, “pinned” in the message string”.  This is Mark Cuban’s public user name on Cyber Dust)

  • SharkTank (all one word, S and T capitalized)

Additionally, I sent one picture of the cover of a book entitled “Google Hacking” from the iPhone to the Android device via Cyber Dust.

The theory behind inputting specific key words and a unique picture into the message string(s) was to be able to quickly search for and identify artifacts that are unique in nature to our “case” after a successful extraction of the data on the devices.  My results were admittedly mixed.

iPhone Results

As many in the mobile forensic world may know, a full physical extraction on any iPhone model 4s and later is not currently possible with commercially-available or open-source forensic tools.  Nevertheless, I attempted to recover data from Cyber Dust on an iPhone 5s running the most current iOS as of the writing of this article using what I have found to be the most effective iOS examination tool on the market - Lantern.  To be blunt, I found nothing.  Of course, there was evidence that the app was installed on the device, which in and of itself should tell a trained examiner something, but that’s about it.  I surmised that the reason for this is probably that the user-input portion of the app runs mainly in the device RAM volatile memory and therefore, absent a full physical extraction, I was not able to recover any probative data from the device.  Often times, some artifacts from device RAM may be written to the empty or unallocated space on the storage medium, but as I was unable to examine that part of the system memory on the iPhone, none of those artifacts could be recovered, even if present.

Android Results

The results from the Android pre-pay/test phone were much more interesting.  I used Cellebrite UFED for PC to make a full physical extraction of the Samsung phone for examination.  I further created a logical extraction and a file system extraction, just to see if there would be any additional evidence found.  Naturally, in an app of this nature, not much data was recovered from either the logical or file system extractions, but the physical extraction yielded some interesting artifacts.

I conducted key word searches at the physical level to try and find all of the above-listed key words on the device.  The search was conducted for both ANSII and Unicode characters to account for any variance.  I did not make the search case-sensitive because I knew that any hits would return, whether capitalized or not.  The key word "Xylophone" was searched first.  Two hits were located, but not from within any app data of Cyber Dust.  Rather, they were recovered from the Samsung key log file, which logs all recent key strokes input into the device and is active by default (file: root/data/com.sec.android.inputmethod/…).  In fact, there were two unique hits for the same key word (Xylophone) in the same key logger.  This is interesting because, while on it’s face, the claim that Cyber Dust does not keep your data may be true, these artifacts(as well as other) were located in a secondary source.  This gives a digital forensic examiner something to work with because it tells us that the data may be recoverable from more than one area. It should be noted, however, that only the sender’s messages (those that were typed on the device being examined) were recovered, not the messages received on the device by whomever he was messaging.

The same evidence was found in the same place for the key words “Bababooey” and “BlogMaverick.”  Both of these key words, as well as the entire text string from the messages containing those key words (as well as some older messages from standard SMS), were recovered from the Samsung key logger file.  While the logger is on by default on Samsung phones, it can sometimes be turned off or replaced by another keyboard.  The limitations of this pre-pay phone prevented us from testing this further with alternative key boards.  I captured some screen shots in Cellebrite UFED that show the key word hits below:

Key Word: Xylophone


Key Word: Bababooey



One interesting thing of note is the presence of the key word “BlogMaverick”.  This turned out to be the only key word that was found in more than one place.  As mentioned earlier, BlogMaverick is Mark Cuban’s public user name on Cyber Dust.  When a user downloads and installs Cyber Dust on his device, several “friends” are added by default.  Among these are “BlogMaverick” and “CDteam” (short for Cyber Dust Team).  Interestingly enough, those two screen names were located within the Cyber Dust app files at: Root/dalvik-cache/data@app@com.radicalapps.cyberdust-1.apk@classes.dex.   

The screen shot of this artifact is below:


Naturally, I’m not a programmer, so I can’t answer the question whether or not these user names were part of the Cyber Dust app by default and permanently implanted in the code or if they appear in this file because messages were routinely received from both of these user names, but the fact remains that there were these two artifacts recovered from within the Cyber Dust app which indicates two contact names at the very least.  If other screen names are added to this list through constant contact as a user, it could prove to be worthwhile recoverable data in the course of an investigation.  Obviously, more prolonged testing should be conducted to help answer these questions.


Picture Recovery on Android Device

As stated earlier, one picture of the cover of a book was sent from the iPhone 5s to the Samsung Android phone for testing purposes.  After conducting a review of the allocated images from the physical extraction as well as the carved unallocated images from the extraction, I found no evidence of the picture.  I further performed a key word search at the physical level for the file name of the picture (IMG_4153.jpg) and no traces of that file name were recovered.  I purposely did not take a screen shot of the picture, suspecting it would be found very easily in the picture database on the device.  Albeit a basic test, this seems to verify that the pictures received on Cyber Dust do not get saved in any form on the device without affirmative action being taken by the user.  It is theoretically possible that a highly trained examiner might be able to recover the image(s) from the device RAM with the proper training and tools, however I’m not aware of any such tools that capture volatile memory from a mobile device. 

This search was not attempted on the iPhone 5s because of the limitations on data recovery on iOS devices as stated previously.

Conclusions

This test has served to not only demonstrate some of the potentially recoverable artifacts on a device using Cyber Dust, but also demonstrates the differences in mobile device security and indeed, some of the purported security of the Cyber Dust app itself.  It’s obvious that Cyber Dust users on an iOS (Apple) platform with a model 4s or later can probably rest easy that their messages are deleted after having been sent and received for 24 seconds.

However, the multitude of difference in Android-platform devices presents us with a little more muddled conclusion as to whether any evidence can be obtained from the use of Cyber Dust.  This initial test dealt with the use of a basic Samsung smart phone running an older operating system.  This begs the questions:  What (if anything) could be recovered from other manufacturer’s devices?  What could be recovered from a Samsung with a newer operating system and/or a device where only a logical extraction is possible?  What might a theoretical examination of the volatile memory of the device present insofar as evidence?  All of these questions and more lead us to the inevitable conclusion that further testing and reverse-engineering of Cyber Dust needs to be conducted. Make no mistake, there were artifacts recovered from the full physical image of the Android device using Cellebrite UFED for PC.  But the artifacts were not all recovered from the Cyber Dust app database and the recovered artifacts were somewhat sporadic in nature (the term SharkTank was not found, although a visual inspection showed it as part of the Samsung key logger file as well).


For Digital Forensic Examiners, the take-away from this test is clear: Even if you are dealing with a case that involves Cyber Dust (or any other private messaging app), it may still be possible to recover data that is valuable to your case.  Will you get the entire picture?  Probably not. But the role of a Digital Forensic Examiner is often to put pieces of a puzzle together and these pieces may certainly prove valuable in many types of investigations.



It’s certain that Mark Cuban and company have come up with a pretty decent app as far as privacy goes.  What’s too early to tell is whether the reverse-engineers and programmers at companies like Cellebrite, XRY, Oxygen Forensics, Magnet Forensics, AccessData and/or Katana Forensics will uncover the need and the skills to work around the app engineering and what implication that may have on future iterations of Cyber Dust.  One thing is universally true in Mobile App Development and thus, Mobile Device Forensics – things are always changing, so it’s a constant game of catch-up between developers and forensic tool engineers to see who can keep up.

Author:
Patrick J. Siewert, SCERS, BCERT, LCE
Owner, Lead Forensic Examiner
Professional Digital Forensic Consulting, LLC
Based in Richmond, Virginia
Available Globally
Web: www.ProDigital4n6.com
Twitter: @ProDigital4n6
Google Plus: +Professional Digital Forensic Consulting, LLC 

AUTHOR'S NOTE: I welcome any and all feedback on these tests as this is the first time I’ve attempted anything like this.  I do realize this was not an all-encompassing scientific exploration, more of an experiment, but I welcome your feedback and comments on this and possibly future testing of apps and tools.

Update: May, 2015:  This is still the most viewed article on our blog, which indicates there's a high degree of interest in it.  We did a follow-up to this article you may want to check out.  It's linked right here: http://prodigital4n6.blogspot.com/2015/04/cyber-dust-privacy-claims-debunked.html
Thanks for all your interest!