Showing posts with label cellular records analysis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cellular records analysis. Show all posts

Thursday, September 1, 2022

Pro Digital is Joining ArcherHall

September 1, 2022

I built something someone wants. So, I sold it to them.

When the happenstance came along that I was introduced to the CEO of ArcherHall, a Sacramento-based nationwide provider of litigation support and eDiscovery services, I took it in stride. We had a great call, but I had no expectation that it would blossom into anything. It did, and over several months of discussions we came up with an exciting plan for the future that works well for everyone.




So here’s what’s changing: Not much. 

I will continue to serve current and future clients in the role of Director of Digital Forensics and eDiscovery for ArcherHall out of the former Pro Digital office & lab in the West End of Richmond, VA. We have worked very hard to cultivate the relationships with the attorney-clients with whom we work consistently, and it is our goal to continue to foster those relationships for years to come. Professional Digital Forensic Consulting (dba Pro Digital) will cease to exist as a business entity, and I will join ArcherHall. Because ArcherHall has more financial backing and people performing the casework, the analysis work on future cases will have the benefit of a team of experts working on them with expanded capabilities of tools, training, experience, and knowledge. It’s a win-win for our current and future clients.


I will continue to teach as much as possible at the University and private sector levels. I thoroughly enjoy teaching and it’s a great “side-hustle”. This blog may be moving, but it will still exist. There are a few other exciting things on the horizon regarding publications, which I’ll announce on my personal Linked In and personal Twitter feeds. I will stay an active and vocal member of the digital forensic community and hope to be able to contribute more as I will not have the time investment overhead of running a business on a daily basis.


That’s the biggest part that will be changing: The administrative side of running a digital forensic consultancy will largely be removed from my responsibilities. Clients can expect more structure, team-based communication and an overall more immersive and responsive experience from me and ArcherHall.


The natural question that would be posed is “why?”  In my multiple conversations and meetings with ArcherHall’s CEO, Chief of Staff and Managing Directors, it became apparent that we share the same approach and values in our role as digital forensic service providers.  Those values include integrity, professionalism and a service-based approach forged with an entrepreneurial spirit.  These are the core values that Pro Digital’s clients have come to expect and will remain as tenants of our practice moving forward.


I’ll wrap up this blog and personal note by thanking everyone who has helped make this possible. When I registered the LLC for Pro Digital back in 2013, I did so as sort of a lark and a fallback position. A little more than a year later, I left full-time law enforcement work and invested in Pro Digital fully and have been churning it ever since. Every close person in my personal and professional circles has helped make this possible in some way or another, from my ex-wife to my children to my current fiancĂ©e. My brother and my sister, both successful business owners who offered so much advice to help get started and stay in business. Experts in other areas of forensic services, including noted authors, other DF entrepreneurs and very smart people in our industry. Mentors at Cellebrite and IACIS and the Virginia State Police and Instructors with the Department of Homeland Security and the US Secret Service, as well as colleagues from my 2012 BCERT class. If you are reading this, you know who you are, and I am forever grateful for your contributions to the success of Pro Digital and me personally.


In closing, I’d only ask that we, as an industry, always strive to be and do better. I’m not perfect, nor am I the professional ombudsman of the digital forensic service industry. I get educated on areas of improvement regularly and take those lessons in the way they are intended. I can always learn more & do better and am regularly excited to do so. Digital Forensics as an industry can also work toward the standards of constant improvement. Our profession deserves it. Our clients and case stakeholders deserve it. And most importantly, the justice system needs it. Our industry will only grow over the coming decades. It’s incumbent upon all of us to nurture the profession and ensure that it remains a path to the truth in the cases we work.


Onward….


-Patrick


Author: 

Patrick J. Siewert

Director of Digital Forensics & eDiscovery

ArcherHall


About the Author:

Patrick Siewert was the Founder & Principal Consultant of Pro Digital Forensic Consulting, based in Richmond, Virginia (USA). In 15 years of law enforcement, he investigated hundreds of high-tech crimes to precedent-setting results and continues to support litigation cases and corporations in private digital forensic practice. Patrick is a graduate of SCERS & BCERT and holds several vendor-neutral and specific certifications in the field of digital forensics and high-tech investigation and is a court-certified expert witness in multiple digital forensic areas. He continues to keep in touch with the public safety community as a Law Enforcement Instructor and Adjunct Professor at Virginia Commonwealth University.

Email: psiewert@archerhall.com

Twitter : @RVA4n6 

Web: https://archerhall.com 

ArcherHall on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/archerhall/ 

Patrick Siewert on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/patrick-siewert-92513445/ 

Monday, June 1, 2020

Beyond Location Data In Cellular Records Analysis


June 1, 2020

Beyond Location Data In Cellular Records Analysis

For reasons I’m not sure I can put a firm grasp on, there still seems to be a debate over the value of cellular call detail records and their strength in being able to prove or disprove location in litigation.  Clearly the location data is generally what is sought after the most, because it carries weight with regard to a particular incident and/or time frame at the heart of the dispute.  However, some still try to debunk this data as “junk science”.  The reasoning for this is a great topic for another article, and is touched upon in our previous article entitled Three Reasons Why Call Detail Records Analysis Is Not “Junk Science”.  However, there’s much more to the cellular records than location data, or at least much more that is ancillary to location data.  This deeper level of analysis can further lend validity to the records themselves and any conclusions drawn from their analysis, location or otherwise.



Dataset #1:  Link Analysis

Along with location data, properly obtained cellular records also tell us a great deal about who our target is talking to, when they are talking and how often.  This is most commonly referred to as link analysis, but effective analysis of these records goes beyond that.  For instance, target is suspected of marital infidelity with a married woman.  The call detail records (CDR) show he calls and texts the married woman several dozen times a day.  A private investigator tracking the married woman spots the two of them together on a particular date and time.  What is likely to happen?  They’ll stop calling or texting each other during that time because they’re in the same location.  In another example, suspect #1 is arrested and charged with robbery.  His defense team has information that he was NOT the only one involved in the robbery, and perhaps was not the primary involved in the robbery.  Analyzing who the suspect called and texted the most leading up to the robbery and afterward can be of great value in determining whom an accomplice may have been.  Usually what we see with link analysis is the people will call and text their loved ones the most – husbands/wives, parents, best friends, etc.  This all goes to show a pattern of usage and helps identify who they talk to the most and potentially, their activity with regard to those people as well.

Dataset #2:  Usage Patterns

Often in conversations with litigators about analysis of these records, we get asked “what if they turned their phone off?” or “What if he simply left his phone at home or at work?” during the time of interest.  All valid questions!  The issue becomes, what can we tell is likely during the time frame of interest in relation to other usage patterns.  If a cheating husband is meeting his paramour in a hotel during his lunch hour once or twice a week and he leaves his cell phone at the office, we’ll be able to tell from looking at 1) the usage patterns from when he is not with his paramour and 2) a pattern of missed calls and/or texts for the period of time he was separated from his phone.  Let’s also not overlook that he may have had a flurry of text messages or calls with the paramour leading up to this activity.  There are very interesting and often very valuable items we can tell by looking at the record, such as: 

·      If the phone rang and went to voicemail
·      If the phone was turned off and calls when directly to voicemail
·      If calls were received and unanswered in succession for a period of time (and later returned)
·      If text messages were received and  unanswered for a period of time (and later returned)
·      Whether any of this activity is normal, as compared to other activity for time frames outside of the time frame of interest

People are creatures of habit.  By analyzing the usage patterns in the records, we can see what their habits are in relation to the use of their device.  This is the single biggest reason we advise all litigators who wish to use these records to obtain at least 30 days of records on either end of the incident in question.  The more data, the better.  Usage patterns are of great value when conducting this analysis.



Dataset #3:  Where They Lay Their Head

Much of usage analysis mentioned previously has little or nothing to do with location.  One area that has to do with location, although not necessarily during the time frame of the alleged incident(s), is where your target lays their head.  As stated earlier, people are creatures of habit.  Their phones are with them virtually all the time.  So even outside of the time frame of the incident, we can likely tell where that person is staying at night.  By in large, during late night and early morning hours, we see the mobile device stationary, only using one sector of one cell site for an extended period.  This information in the records tells us likely where they lay their head.  By filtering down to late night & early morning hours, we can also see if they have more than one place where they may stay at night.  This typically generates a “hot list” of cell sites that are used most often, and this is also included in any reports we generate.  It’s relevant insofar as it shows the finder of fact or opposing counsel that where their stated address is may not be where they stay.  It could also provide additional information for follow-up if the house and likely person with whom they are staying can be determined.  It’s a fantastic piece of evidentiary data!

Wrapping It Up

As illustrated briefly here, there’s more to cellular call detail records analysis than simple location.  These points also further prove that the proper and effective analysis of this data is not “junk science”, rather there may be a contingent of analysts who simply don’t have the ability or desire to perform this type of higher-level analysis in their cases.  Ignorance of the power and effective use of the data does not make the data invalid.  By looking deeper into the data, we can start to sort out what may help to prove or disprove the claims in the case.  It could also help shed light upon or validate who else may be involved in the matter, whether previously known or not.  The ability to analyze behavior patterns in the record cannot be over-stated either.  At the heart of any digital forensic practice is a person, whether it is behind the keyboard, phone screen or a cellular subscriber.  People behave in patterns.  Your analyst should be able to identify those patterns and determine whether or not they are of relevance in your case.  Happy hunting!

Author:
Patrick J. Siewert
Principal Consultant
Professional Digital Forensic Consulting, LLC
Virginia DCJS #11-14869
Based in Richmond, Virginia
Available Wherever You Need Us!


We Find the Truth for a Living!

Computer Forensics -- Mobile Forensics -- Specialized Investigation
About the Author:
Patrick Siewert is the Principal Consultant of Pro Digital Forensic Consulting, based in Richmond, Virginia.  In 15 years of law enforcement, he investigated hundreds of high-tech crimes, incorporating digital forensics into the investigations, and was responsible for investigating some of the highest jury and plea bargain child exploitation investigations in Virginia court history.  Patrick is a graduate of SCERS, BCERT, the Reid School of Interview & Interrogation and multiple online investigation schools (among others).  He is a Cellebrite Certified Operator and Physical Analyst as well as certified in cellular call detail analysis and mapping.  He continues to hone his digital forensic expertise in the private sector while growing his consulting & investigation business marketed toward litigators, professional investigators and corporations, while keeping in touch with the public safety community as a Law Enforcement Instructor.
Email:  Inquiries@ProDigital4n6.com

Wednesday, October 30, 2019

Three Reasons Why Call Detail Records Analysis Is Not “Junk Science”



October 31, 2019

Three Reasons Why Call Detail Records Analysis Is Not “Junk Science”

Since introducing our private sector clients to the impact that cellular call detail records (CDR) analysis & mapping can have on their cases, we’ve had a lot of robust discussions with litigators and clients about the veracity and value of this evidence.  CDR analysis has been used for decades in law enforcement to help prove or disprove the approximate location of criminal defendants in major crimes.  Only in the past several years have civil litigators and insurance companies also been introduced to the value that this evidence can have on their cases and/or claims investigations.  In the time we’ve been conducting CDR analysis, we’ve worked varying types of cases from criminal prosecution for smaller prosecutor’s offices to domestic litigation to help prove/disprove cohabitation to high-dollar insurance claims to help determine if the claim and associated statements made under oath are verifiable with regard to location.  This specialty offshoot of digital forensics requires constant knowledge updating with regard to carrier practices and specialized training and tools to be able to perform these analyses effectively.


However mainly among the Criminal Defense Bar, the notion has been put forth that CDR analysis may be “junk science” and therefore potentially unreliable as evidence in legal proceedings.  One such high-profile case in which CDR analysis was used to obtain a conviction was the case of State v. Adnan Syed, chronicled in the Serial Podcast.  However, as we’ve seen more recent developments in that case unfold, the “junk science” claim doesn’t necessarily lie with the practice, rather with the potential practitioner.  Indeed, even in computer forensics, certain vendors of forensic tools like to claim their tool has been “validated in court”, when in reality it is the examiner and their competence that needs to be validated in court.  The tool (or in this case, the cellular records) is/are just a dataset that needs to be analyzed competently to be introduced as evidence in a legal proceeding. 

Toward the end of establishing that CDR analysis is not “junk science”, here are three salient points that will help debunk the myth that these records and their associated analysis is not worthy of evidentiary status.

Reason # 1:  Cellular Records Are “Pure” Evidence

What do we mean by “pure” evidence?  Consider for a moment other types of digital evidence that are analyzed for use in court, such as the cell phone itself or a computer system.  These items are generally affected by the user to a great degree and therefore can be open to some scrutiny about the weight and value they hold.  Cellular Records are only available via court order or search warrant to the cellular provider.  A Verizon Wireless customer cannot call customer support and ask for their cellular call detail records with historical cell site data.  The provider will not provide this data this absent legal process.  This means the user has very limited (if any) ability to manipulate the data, which makes the evidence about as pure as it gets. 

Furthermore, the record-keeper has no vested interest in altering the evidence.  In fact, they have every reason to maintain better, more accurate records!  It is a fact within the cellular industry that CDRs were never meant to be used as evidence in legal proceedings.  CDRs are kept by cellular providers so they can log and analyze their own networks for efficiency and to increase overall customer experience on the network.  Simply put, the records are kept for customer service purposes and cellular companies don’t make money by having poor customer service.  It is a fortunate byproduct that these records may be obtained via legal process and analyzed for potential use in legal proceedings.  This is why cellular providers don’t maintain these records indefinitely, as detailed in our 2017 article Cellular Provider Record Retention Periods.

Name another type of digital evidence that the user never touches and to which they generally don’t have access!

Reason # 2:  Automated Tools Have Greatly Decreased The Human Error Factor 

Back in 2001 when the incident detailed in season 1 of the Serial Podcast, there were few, if any, automated tools with which to conduct CDR analysis.  In modern casework, we have many options for automated tools analysis, including CellHawk, ZetX, CASTviz, Map Link, Pen Link, as well as some others.  Use of automated tools can save time and greatly reduce error, but they come with a few warnings:

·      Not all tools are created equally.  If you’re using a tool that is free [to law enforcement], you’re generally getting what you pay for. 
·      Don’t rely on the tool to do all of the work.  Automated tools are great, but they cannot tell you if someone likely shut their phone off or sent a call to voicemail or left their phone in one location while committing an offense somewhere else.  Only manual analysis of the data and the behavior of the user can help verify these conclusions.

·      VALIDATE!  If an automated tool is telling you something, make sure to always refer back to the original record for validation.  If an automated tool is citing a GPS coordinate for location, make sure you validate there is actually a cell site at that location. 


Reason # 3:  Trained, Experienced Analysts Don’t Deal in “Junk Science”

One of the traps digital forensic examiners of all ilk are susceptible to fall is the drawing of conclusions not based on fact.  While it’s true that a trained, experienced professional may reach conclusions based upon device activity, those same conclusions have to be rooted in some facts at some point.  The trap that sometimes rears its ugly head is when we reach conclusions that are either outside of our expertise or are not supported by the data. 

There are several traps documented in litigation over the course of the life of CDR analysis in legal proceedings that have led to the claim of “junk science”.  Probably the biggest of these (and the one cited in the article linked above and again here) are conclusions about cell site range.  As analysts, we are not cellular engineers and we cannot be engaged in speculation or discussion about the “range” of a particular cell site.  This is why in most cases we approximate location of the target device in the investigation and DO NOT get entwined in discussions about cell site range.  Even if we were fortunate enough to have propagation maps from the cellular provider which detail the effective/optimal range of a cell site, we still won’t draw conclusions about range.  It is not within the expertise of most analysts to discuss range.  That is for a cellular engineer to conclude, not an analyst of cellular records.



There are behaviors and activity that the records can tell us, however.  A trained analyst can usually tell of the phone was off or if a call was sent straight to voice mail or if the phone was left in one location for a prolonged period.  At the heart of the records is usage behavior.  Is there a pattern of behavior that is not adhered to during the time of the alleged incident?  Is there link analysis that can be done to confirm likely associates and/or accomplices?  If there are alleged accomplices, does normally text and/or call activity cease with that person during the time frame of the incident?  All of these items and more can help lead a trained, experienced analyst come to conclusions within a reasonable degree of certainty, but with most of these items, we require a larger dataset to compare the behavior at the time of incident with the behavior at other times.  An analyst cannot identify these behaviors with 24 or 48 hours worth of records.  This is not enough data from which to draw conclusions about behavior.  This is also why we highly advise obtaining at least 30 days of records on either end of the incident, preferably more.  More data is better when it comes to CDR analysis.



The ultimate test of whether or not the conclusions based upon trained, experienced analysis of the records is “junk science” lies with the competencies of the analyst.  One who draws conclusions not based in fact is what leads to an otherwise valid form of data analysis to be dubbed “junk science”.

Wrapping It Up

In any forensic discipline, there is a possibility for human error or oversight.  We’re not infallible, after all, and we can’t be expected to be perfect all the time.  But CDR analysis is the only one in which the term “junk science” has been bandied about quite a bit.  Deeper inspection of the issues involved in each case where this claim has been made can be lessons for current and future analysts to read and take heed.  It’s when our conclusions span beyond the breadth of our expertise and what the data tells us that we get into trouble.  Ultimately, everyone wants to see justice done.  If we can use CDR analysis successfully in litigation without reaching past our ability into conclusions that are open to extreme scrutiny, justice will be served. 

Author:
Patrick J. Siewert
Principal Consultant
Professional Digital Forensic Consulting, LLC
Virginia DCJS #11-14869
Based in Richmond, Virginia
Available Wherever You Need Us!


We Find the Truth for a Living!

Computer Forensics -- Mobile Forensics -- Specialized Investigation
About the Author:
Patrick Siewert is the Principal Consultant of Pro Digital Forensic Consulting, based in Richmond, Virginia.  In 15 years of law enforcement, he investigated hundreds of high-tech crimes, incorporating digital forensics into the investigations, and was responsible for investigating some of the highest jury and plea bargain child exploitation investigations in Virginia court history.  Patrick is a graduate of SCERS, BCERT, the Reid School of Interview & Interrogation and multiple online investigation schools (among others).  He is a Cellebrite Certified Operator and Physical Analyst as well as certified in cellular call detail analysis and mapping.  He continues to hone his digital forensic expertise in the private sector while growing his consulting & investigation business marketed toward litigators, professional investigators and corporations, while keeping in touch with the public safety community as a Law Enforcement Instructor.
Email:  Inquiries@ProDigital4n6.com
Twitter: @ProDigital4n6